Supreme Court freezes Brazil betting lawsuits as industry plea waits
Industry associations ANJL and IBJR asked Fux to suspend the ban on 28 September; the Prosecutor General filed on Friday and won on Sunday
Supreme Court Justice Luiz Fux has frozen every lower-court case against Brazil’s betting ban, granting the Prosecutor General’s request in just two days while the industry’s own plea has waited 42 days.
The decision, signed on Sunday 8 November and published by the Supreme Federal Court (STF) on Monday, stays all cases challenging Provisional Measure (MP) 1.394/2026 until the court rules on four constitutional challenges to the ban imposed by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva.
Two days for the PGR, 42 for the industry
The Prosecutor General’s Office (PGR) filed its request on Friday 6 November. Industry groups ANJL and IBJR had asked Fux to suspend the MP on 28 September, three days after it was signed, describing it as a request for the ban’s “immediate suspension”.
Instead of ruling, Fux called a public hearing, which took place on 3 November.
“It’s very clear that, from the start, there has been a huge imbalance in the way this issue is being handled,” said Frederico Manssur, a partner at Brazilian betting law firm Natal & Manssur.
An executive at a licensed operator, speaking on condition of anonymity, put it more bluntly: “Why doesn’t Fux decide? If the situation is urgent, why doesn’t he rule on the injunction request?
“Why wait so long? The public hearing has already happened. There was no need for a public hearing, but they held one,” he added. “That’s what bothers the industry.”
Asked by NEXT.io when the cases would be judged, the STF press office said there was “no forecast” and that Fux “has to release the cases for judgment”.
What Fux ordered
The PGR argued that individual rulings in lower courts, such as those for Stake Brazil and CDA Gaming, created “legal uncertainty and asymmetric application of the rule”.
Fux, rapporteur of the betting cases at the STF, agreed. He said the risk of conflicting decisions was made worse because the cases involved “the potential release of an activity recognised as harmful and of high social risk”, citing his remarks at the hearing and his August vote on land-based gambling.
The executive said the outcome was no surprise. “I knew there would be no room with Fux,” he said, pointing to the justice’s previous record on gambling.
Provisionally, Fux is empowered to take the decision alone. The law gives the power to suspend lower-court cases to the full court, by an absolute majority of its 11 justices.
Fux granted the stay alone as an urgent injunction, which the plenary must now confirm. Manssur said Fux was entitled to do so, and Justices Flávio Dino and Gilmar Mendes took the same route in 2025.
‘He killed it’: operators left with no route back
The stay hits every operator that went to court. Stake Brazil won an injunction in São Paulo on 8 October, which was suspended the next day. CDA Gaming’s Casa de Apostas, Betsul and Jogo Online were cleared by an appeals judge on 3 November, a ruling since suspended. The PGR listed 13 cases, all in São Paulo state federal courts. No licensed operator is currently online in Brazil.
“He killed any company’s chance of taking any action,” Manssur said. “In the final part of the decision, he writes ‘ALL’ in capital letters.”
That includes claims over licence fees, he added. Operators paid R$30m (€4.9m) each for five-year licences, and are preparing to seek the return of around R$2.5bn (€408m). Not even a proportional refund can be discussed until the court decides, Manssur said: “That is confiscation.”
The operator executive said his company was weighing its options with lawyers. “There is room to appeal, but we need to be a little cautious,” he said.
IBJR said when it challenged the ban: “The decision is hasty and causes serious legal uncertainty.” Lawyers for Stake Brazil did not respond to NEXT.io’s request for comment by the time of publication.
No date and no deadline
Fux’s order now needs the full court’s backing, either in a virtual plenary session or in a joint trial of all betting cases, which court president Edson Fachin signalled on 4 November. In older cases on the 2023 betting law, Dino has yet to return files he asked to review.
“Had he scheduled the case, this decision would make complete sense,” Manssur said. “If it isn’t scheduled, it’s another mistake and another direct interference in the sector.”
In Congress, the MP’s first 60-day term ends on 23 November and is extended automatically. It lapses on 4 March 2027 if lawmakers do not vote on it, and the joint committee that must review it has yet to be set up.
Fonte: NEXT.io